Skip to main content
The HS/HSL is a part of the University of Maryland, Baltimore | My UMB The Elm UM Shuttle Google Apps@UMaryland Blackboard

601 West Lombard Street
Baltimore MD 21201-1512

Reference: 410-706-7996
Circulation: 410-706-7928

Systematic Review Service

Systematic Reviews Defined

A systematic review is “…a review of a clearly formulated question that uses systematic and explicit methods to identify, select and critically appraise relevant research, and to collect and analyze data from the studies that are included in the review.” (Cochrane Handbook)  Combing the results of several studies "gives a more reliable and precise estimate of an intervention’s effectiveness than one study alone." (Centre for Reviews and Dissemination

Systematic reviews differ from narrative reviews, which are often authored by experts in a field and are generally narrative summaries of a topic.

The Systematic Review Process

  • Identify a clinical problem
  • Develop a review protocol
  • Locate Studies
  • Select relevant studies
  • Appraise the quality of the research
  • Collect data from individual studies
  • Synthesize and summarize the findings of studies
  • Document methodology

Introduction to Conducting Systematic Reviews

This 30 minute video will walk you through the process of conducting a systematic review.

Before starting

Clarify your review topic
• Decide if a systematic review is the best approach to answer the question (Grant and Booth identified 14 types of reviews)
• Determine if you have the necessary time and resources
• Form a review team (this is not a solo activity!)
• Expect a slow and lengthy process

Timeline for a review

Estimated timeline for completing a Cochrane systematic review

         

          Month                   Activity

           1 – 2                   Preparation of protocol.

           3 – 8                   Searches for published and unpublished studies.

           2 – 3                   Pilot test of eligibility criteria.

           3 – 8                   Inclusion assessments.

           3                        Pilot test of ‘Risk of bias’ assessment.

           3 – 10                 Validity assessments.

           3                        Pilot test of data collection.

           3 – 10                 Data collection.

           3 – 10                 Data entry.

           5 – 11                 Follow up of missing information.

           8 – 10                 Analysis.

           1 – 11                 Preparation of review report.

           12 –                    Keeping the review up-to-date.

 

 

Source: Higgins JPT, Green S (editors). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org.