Skip to main content
The HS/HSL is a part of the University of Maryland, Baltimore | My UMB The Elm UM Shuttle Google Apps@UMaryland Blackboard
Library Logo

601 West Lombard Street
Baltimore MD 21201-1512

Reference: 410-706-7996
Circulation: 410-706-7928

Open Access: Predatory Publishing

What is Predatory Publishing?

Many researchers have received manuscript solicitations from journals they have never heard of. Further investigation may show an editorial board full of well-known names and photos of nice office buildings where the editorial offices are located. However, there is a chance that the solicitation is from one of a subset of dishonest publishers who take advantage of open access and the academic need to publish, making money without furthering scholarship.

These predatory journals exploit the author-pays model of open access publishing. Problems with these publishers include:

  • Excessive or opaque fee structures
  • Spurious editorial boards
  • Publication without approval
  • Lack of peer review

Evaluating Open Access Journals and Publishers

Be wary of solicitations to submit to unknown journals or to become an editorial board member. Here are some ways to assess the quality and authority of a journal or publisher:

  • Check out the publisher's website. Is complete, verifiable contact information listed? If only a web contact form is provided, be cautious.
  • Look at the editorial board for the journal in question. Does it list recognized experts and their affiliations? Contact board members about their experience with the journal or the publisher. (Note: some predatory journals list experts as members of their editorial boards without permission, so contacting these researchers is key.)
  • Read some published articles from the journal to get a sense of their quality. You may also try contacting some of the authors to ask about their experience writing for the journal.
  • Does the journal prominently display its policy on author fees? Predatory journals may not mention an author fee when soliciting an article, but then will send a huge invoice after acceptance.
  • Similarly, does the journal describe its peer review process on their website?
  • Take note of whether the journal is a member of an association like the Directory of Open Access Journals or the Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association. These are not a guarantee of quality, but there are criteria publishers need to meet to be accepted into these groups.
  • Newly launched predatory journals may try to feign a reputation by posting a false Journal Impact Factor or claiming to be included in important databases such as PubMed or Scopus. Legitimate journals will acknowledge being new and not having these credentials.

Resources

Open Access Publishers

Below are a few resources that will help you locate reputable OA journals. The first link is a directory of OA journals that have been reviewed for quality, and the other links are a couple of trustworthy publishers that produce a large number of OA journals.

Other Publishing Resources

Questions?